Common Mistakes When Refinancing to Cut Repayments

Lowering your monthly repayments is a sound goal, but a few common missteps can cost more than they save. Here is what to check first.

Hero Image for Common Mistakes When Refinancing to Cut Repayments

Refinancing can lower your monthly repayments, but only if the new loan saves you more than it costs. For Joondalup homeowners, the key is to compare the total cost of switching against the saving, not just the headline repayment.

A lower repayment can come from a lower rate, a longer loan term, or both. Only the first one reduces what you pay overall. Below are the mistakes worth avoiding before you refinance your home loan.

Mistake 1: Judging a Refinance by the Monthly Repayment Alone

A lower monthly repayment does not always mean a cheaper loan. If the repayment falls only because the term is longer, you will pay more interest over the life of the loan.

ASIC's responsible lending guidance says a borrower should be told clearly when lower repayments come from a longer term, because of the extra interest that follows. Ask for the repayment shown on your remaining term, as well as on any new term, so you can compare like with like.

A longer term can still suit some households, especially when cashflow is tight. Just choose it knowingly, and consider making extra repayments when you can.

How Much Can a Lower Rate Actually Save Each Month?

A lower interest rate reduces your repayment, and the size of the reduction depends on your loan amount, remaining term and the rate gap. Our mortgage repayment calculator lets you test your own numbers.

Consider a Joondalup homeowner with $500,000 left on a 25 year loan. At an illustrative rate of 6.75% p.a., the principal and interest repayment is about $3,455 a month. If a lender offered an illustrative 6.25% p.a. on the same balance and term, the repayment would be about $3,298. That is roughly $157 a month less.

Before switching, the homeowner adds up the costs. A discharge fee and an application fee may apply, and a broker fee if one is charged. If these come to a few hundred dollars, the saving would repay them within a few months. If the costs were several thousand dollars, the payback would take much longer. In this scenario the costs were modest, so the switch went ahead and the homeowner kept the same 25 year term. The repayment fell without adding any interest from a longer term. These figures are illustrative only, and your result will depend on your lender, deposit and circumstances.

Mistake 2: Overlooking Exit Fees and Switching Costs

Switching costs can include a discharge fee, an application fee and, on a fixed loan, a break fee. Moneysmart also notes that a borrower with less than 20 per cent equity may face lenders mortgage insurance on the new loan.

For most home loans taken out since 1 July 2011, lenders cannot charge an exit fee just for ending the loan. A break fee on leaving a fixed rate early and a discharge fee are not covered by that ban, so check both with your current lender.

Ready to get started?

Book a chat with a Mortgage Broker at Mortgage Broker Perth today.

Coming Off a Fixed Rate: When to Refinance

The ideal time to look at refinancing a fixed loan is in the months before the fixed rate period ends, so you avoid a break fee. When a fixed term ends, loans commonly roll to a variable rate that may be higher than what other lenders offer.

Your lender can tell you the exact end date and what your repayments will become. If you want help comparing your options, our fixed rate expiry team can walk you through the choices, including whether to lock in a new fixed rate or move to variable. A fixed rate gives certainty but can limit extra repayments and carry a break fee if you leave early. A variable rate moves with the market but usually offers features like an offset account or redraw.

Mistake 3: Forgetting Features Like Offset and Redraw

A lower rate on a loan with fewer features may not save you money. An offset account reduces the interest charged by counting your savings against the loan balance, and redraw lets you access extra repayments you have made.

If you currently use an offset account, check that the new loan has one, and whether it comes with an annual package fee. Features can be worth paying for if you use them. If you do not, a basic loan with a sharper rate may suit you more.

Mistake 4: Adding Extra Borrowing Without Realising It

Rolling a car loan, credit card or renovation costs into your mortgage can lower your total monthly outgoings, but you pay interest on that debt over a much longer time. Debt consolidation into a home loan can help cashflow, but a five year debt spread across 25 years usually costs more in interest unless you pay it down faster.

If you are looking at this option, our debt consolidation loans page explains how it works. Borrowing extra also means you are no longer doing a like-for-like refinance, so the lender will assess your income and expenses more closely.

If part of the loan is used for an investment property, tax treatment can change. Speak with your accountant before restructuring any loan linked to a rental property, as this guidance depends on how the money is used.

Mistake 5: Not Checking Whether You Qualify Before You Apply

APRA requires banks and other ADIs to assess new borrowers at a rate at least 3 percentage points above the loan rate, so a loan you hold now might be assessed differently if you move lenders. Non-bank lenders are not bound by this buffer but must still meet responsible lending obligations. APRA has said that borrowers seeking to refinance are assessed case by case, and past repayment behaviour can be taken into account.

A clean repayment history, usually looked at over about 12 months, helps. If your circumstances have changed, such as a lower income or a new debt, it is worth knowing early. A loan health check can help you see whether you are likely to qualify before you apply.

If you already have a loan under the Australian Government 5% Deposit Scheme, refinancing outside a participating lender means you lose the scheme benefit, so check that first.

Our home loan refinance service can compare lenders on your behalf and explain the costs and trade-offs. We are required to act in your interests when recommending a loan, and that includes telling you when staying put makes more sense.

If you live in or near Joondalup and want to know whether a lower repayment is within reach, call one of our team or book an appointment at a time that works for you.

Frequently Asked Questions

Will refinancing always reduce my monthly repayments?

Not always. Repayments fall if you secure a lower rate or extend your term, but a longer term means more interest overall. Compare the total cost, not just the monthly figure.

What costs can come with refinancing a home loan?

Costs can include a discharge fee, an application fee and a break fee if you leave a fixed rate early. Lenders mortgage insurance may also apply if you have less than 20 per cent equity.

When is the right time to refinance a fixed rate loan?

Many borrowers review their options in the months before the fixed rate period ends, which helps avoid a break fee. Your lender can confirm your end date and the rate your loan will move to.

Can I refinance if my circumstances have changed?

Possibly. Lenders assess refinance applications case by case and consider your repayment history and current finances. A loan health check can help you see whether you are likely to qualify before you apply.


Ready to get started?

Book a chat with a Mortgage Broker at Mortgage Broker Perth today.